CUTTER CONSULTING GROUP

E75: Recruiting Week: Stop buying pens

December 29, 2023


What alternative method does Jason suggest for a more accurate evaluation of a candidate's abilities?

“Sell me this pen.”


Despite what hiring managers think, and what movies have shown people, this is not the best way to know if someone can sell.


I cover why it’s not effective and what works way better to assess if your candidate can actually sell.

  • Show Transcript

    Welcome to the fifth and final instalment of recruiting week. This is episode 75 this is the sales experience podcast. My name again is Jason Cutter.


    So glad that you’re here. So excited. If you’ve been going through this whole week, we’ve been talking a lot about recruiting, which can apply to both recruiting managers, HR sales managers, but also to the employee, to the applicant.


    If you’re a candidate, you’re trying to get a sales job, you want to get into sales or you’ve been hired for a sales job at this point right now you’ve got one. At some point you’re probably going to change companies and so all of this is important to understand and know both how to be successful in your current role in your career as a sales professional and then also things to look for as you’re going after other jobs.


    You’re making a change, you’re going through a process with the company because as much as they’re interviewing you, you are also interviewing them and I’ll tell you, life is too short to do something you don’t like or work somewhere you don’t enjoy.


    And so you want to make sure as a candidate that you want to be there as much as they want you to be there. Don’t get oversold on a job if you don’t get a good feeling if you don’t think it’s going to be a good fit. Today, what I want to talk about in this episode is the classic, I think this is a terrible interview question, which is sell me this pen. A lot of sales organizations do it.


    It’s been in some movies, sales managers, recruiting managers think it’s cool. They want to see what people come up with. In my opinion, there’s two ways, maybe three ways that this is going to go. One is everyone’s seen the movies or researched it online. Literally you can go and watch YouTube videos about how to sell me this pen and how to do it perfectly and then be amazing.


    So if somebody does that and knows exactly what to do, then either that tells you as a recruiting manager that they’re amazing at doing research or they want to make sure they do it right, but that’s not authentically how they think. Now they’re just giving you the answers they think you want and they’re not being themselves who maybe they can’t sell pens, like maybe that’s not who they are.


    On the other end of the spectrum could be the people who they can’t sell you a pen. Like you say, sell me this pen or sell me this notepad and they literally fall apart and they’re a mess. That could be a good indication that they don’t have the sales skills. However, I don’t think that’s super fair because maybe you’re testing to see if they have that sales chops as a fundamental or the experience they’re coming with.


    But unless you’re selling pens and you’re trying to hire people who only have pen selling experience, then you’re going to teach that person how to sell whatever your product or service is. And so there’s other questions and other things that would be fundamentally better to put them through. Now there’s the middle category, which is the people you say, sell me this pen.


    They’ve never really heard about that before and they actually do a good job and you can see who they truly are and of course that’s great, but again, is that the best way to go? In my experience has just from hiring, looking at lots of interview processes, studying it within many organizations. I don’t think that’s really the best thing to be looking for. You know, I think there’s a lot of standard interview questions, which people are just going to have canned responses for us.


    You always want to watch out for that. For me, in my interview process, as I mentioned a couple episodes ago, I’m really about fundamentally finding who the person is and picking up on the things that are going to be applicable and beneficial for what we’re hiring for and the things that are going to be challenging. I want to know who they are.


    What I really want to do is I want to test them in the interview for how they think, you know, thinking on the fly, selling me this pen and you know, being able to come up with this sales pitch on the fly is great. I think one of the better things to do is to really look at what they’ve done in the past as it relates to what you are selling now and okay, so maybe they have completely different experience but they have anything close by.


    I think a better question ago is, all right, so you used to sell x, why don’t you sell me that? Like walk me through your process, tell me the script you use to use. Pitch me like I’m a prospect trying to buy washers and dryers, like whatever it is that used to sell, sell me that and then see how that process goes. See if their style matches what you know of your style for your organization.


    That’s a much better fit because let them be them, let them do what they do best. Instead of try to throw out this be in my experience scenario at them of selling the pen. Again, if you’d say, sell me the pen, you got the people who cram for the test and you’re not seeing who they really are. You got the people who just fail and that may or may not be a bit applicable.


    And then you’ve got the people who pass and it’s really about what matters to you. If you say sell me Washer and dryer like you used to do, they’re going to go into their mode, they’re going to be comfortable. And what you’re going to see is they’re not going to put on a front, they’re going to be who they are in the sales process.


    Do they go into a long pitch and a monologue to start out where they tell you how amazing and great they are, which I actually covered last week and I think is a terrible strategy that, people do. Or are they going to ask you lots of questions to start out figuring out what you need, how big your family is, how big your space is, what you need a washer and dryer for what kind of clothes, how dirty things get.


    Do you have work clothes? Do you have delicate? Are they going to do an analysis? They can ask lots of questions. They get to figure out the root of what you need, what your budget is, and then they’re going to advise some solutions. What it really comes down to and what you’re really looking for is how do they sell what they used to sell? What is their process? What do they say? How does it feel?


    How do you feel as the potential prospect and then how does that relate to what your company does and what you no works well for a sales person, for an account executive in your current role. That’s the most important thing, and again, there is no right or wrong.


    If you know that your product or service is sold really well by long monologues in the beginning where there’s a lot of education that needs to take place because somebody, the prospect doesn’t really know about you or the service you provide or the problem you’re solving and so there’s education then that’s important to you and you want to make sure you’re hiring people who are okay with that, who are okay with educational, you know, kind of speeches and intros in the beginning to get people interested or excited or understanding it and then go into the questions.


    If you know that doesn’t work for you, then you need more of a question-based one. If you’ve gotten a sales cycle, short sale cycle, it’s just got a match for you. What makes sense and when you’re hiring salespeople, the number one thing I’ve found that to be most successful as far as questions go is having them sell what they’ve sold in the past.


    That’s relative to what you do now and seeing how that goes and is that a match for you now? I will tell you, and I’m not going to go through it on this because I don’t have time in this episode, but if you want my one killer recruiting technique question, it’s actually a, I call it a game, although they don’t always think it’s fun. If you want that one thing that I do every single time and literally I’ve done this for years and nothing else matters other than this one thing.


    I base almost my whole decision on hiring somebody just on the results of this one game. Air quotes. If you want that, send me a message through Keter consulting group.com you know, send it through the context. Send me an email, find me on LinkedIn and then just say recruiting game in the message and then we can hop on the line and chat about it. Or I can send you a message and explain it.


    But outside of that one crazy game, the single question that’s really important outside of why they want to be there, why they want the money. If you’re looking at sales technique, this is why the sell me this pen. It’s like I want to see how you are as a sales person, not as a person, you know, not as in your life and your goals and your dreams and your hopes, but how are you at the actual technique of sales.


    I want you to, you know, sell me what you sold in the past. Just do what used to do. Walk me through it, take as much time as you need and let’s just go through it and see how it goes. The other part I want to bring up, which ties in with what I covered yesterday in practicing like you fight, you know as per the military is that when you’re doing sales and when you’re testing someone in their sales process, make sure that it fits the mode that you’re doing.


    If you do in person interviews and you tell someone to sell you something or talk to you about what they sold in the past and you’re doing that face to face, but you have 100% phone job that’s not fair on two levels on one, maybe they’re really good on the phone and the face to face is really gonna throw them off.


    Plus interviews, it’s already nervous. You know, there’s a lot of pressure and so that’s not always the most accurate, but on the other end you also don’t get a feeling for how they are on the phone. Some people sound really good in person, do really well vibe off of somebody in person and rolling with things over the phone.


    They’re not listening, they’re not picking up on cues and they’re just not a good phone salesperson. Always make sure that you’re doing a part of your interview and the sales part, especially when it comes down to this sales test, it’s why I’m bringing this up now. When you’re testing them or asking questions about selling or having them sell you something, have it match the sales process you’re actually doing at your company.


    If it’s over the phone, make sure you ask this question of them over the phone and see how it feels to be a prospect with them over the phone.


    If you’re like, yet it sounds good, let me grab my credit card, you know, have my money. Then you know that they are going to be a good fit for you over the phone. If you’re going through the phone call and you’re like, this is like pulling teeth and this is terrible and I want to stop talking to you right now, it’s not a good fit. Same thing in person.


    If you know in person it’s going really well. Then you put them in front of anybody else and you know they’re going to do well. Hopefully that helps you their recruiting.


    Thank you for listening to this episode this week. Make sure to subscribe. iTunes, Stitcher, Spotify, Soundcloud, Google on the cutter consulting group.com website. The sales experience podcast is also on LinkedIn if you want to follow it there and get updates, special episodes, anything like that. I appreciate you being here. Thanks for listening for another week. This closes recruiting week, and as


    Always, remember that everything in life is sales and people remember the experience you gave them.


Become a Certified Authentic Persuader

Get the ebooks to help you close more deals

Visit Selling Effectiveness for more tips and get help

Follow Jason on LinkedIn

Or go to Jason’s HUB – www.JasonCutter.com


By Jason Cutter February 19, 2025
What does it take to build the ideal Sales Experience? Why does it even matter? Maybe you think you already have one. You are a professional sales ops leader. You have put everything you can in place to help your salespeople sell more. You have optimized the processes so that your sales team can focus on one thing – selling. But I promise – even if you think all of that is true, it’s not. The Reality: No Perfect Sales Experience Exists I have never seen any company or team with the ‘ideal’ Sales Experience and operation. And to be honest – I have never built one successfully. Why would I admit that? Because the ideal Sales Experience is aspirational and business, teams, processes, and customer needs/desires are constantly changing. So as soon as you put new processes in place, something else needs to change and evolve. The Scalable Sales Success Iceberg In my Scalable Sales Success Iceberg – there are 24 categories that, when built out, create a scalable sales machine – where you can add in an input and get way more output. I would love to see companies have all 24 categories set up and running optimally. But that’s not even possible – because, as I mentioned, things are always changing. Focusing on the Biggest Levers Here is the key – to build the ideal Sales Experience takes focus on the biggest levers. The ones that, when pulled, create the biggest and best results. There are many processes and systems that you can put in place – but those are going to get you a few percentage points of improvement. Instead of putting it all in here, I want to make you a special offer. Email me at jason@sellingeffectiveness.com with your mailing address, and I will mail you the book that I co-wrote with Nick Glimsdahl called Reasons Not To Focus On The Sales Experience. It will be your starter guide, facilitating the creation of your ideal Sales Experience.
By Jason Cutter February 18, 2025
The Numbers Game Mentality is a Losing Strategy Sales is no longer a “numbers game.” You cannot succeed, long term, by focusing on volume of activity. Making a million dials, sending a million emails, knocking on a million doors (the first two are way easier than that last one) is a scorched earth strategy that will sink your business. You can’t out-dial a bad sales process. It will lead to even more bad online reviews. You can’t out-email a terrible sales funnel process that requires people to jump through poorly planned hoops. You can’t out-knock your way past slimy tactics and bad products/services. The Danger of the "Every No Gets Me Closer to a Yes" Mindset The whole “every no gets me one step closer to a yes” mentally is dangerous. That mindset and strategy assumes that it’s a numbers game. That the only thing that matters is finding the right person who will buy from you. Potentially, no matter what you even say – they are just ready to buy. Not only will this destroy any online reputation you have it will also wreak havoc on your team. It is the fastest and best way to burn out your team. It will lead to a revolving door or hiring, training, and quitting as people realize how unfun the game is you have built and how hard it is to be successful. It will also feel like a mismatch – very few people (and hopefully even less over time) are long-term excited about the business model of calling 500 people a day in hopes of making a few sales. If It’s Not a Numbers Game, Then What Is It? It’s quality over quantity. [Now…note – it does take a certain quantity of activity to fill a sales pipeline. So I am not saying that your sales team can just sit and wait for people to fall into their pipeline with money in hand.] It’s about the Sales Experience. It’s about your team ensuring that they are providing the right and best experience for that potential customer – in a way that sets them up to get into the buying mood and mode. All that matters is the Sales Experience. How can you support your team in terms of the quantity of activity to fill a pipeline, and then the quality of interaction that leads to sales? What Does an Ideal Sales Experience Look Like? What does that look like – the ideal Sales Experience? It’s when your team understands that the potential customer they are speaking with only cares about themselves. They don’t care about the salesperson, your company or the product. They are only focused on themselves. It’s when the Discovery/Empathy portion of the conversation is the most important part. Does your team realize that everything after Discovery – when done right – is just a presentation of the solution? It’s the fact that when you combine the parts of the Authentic Persuasion Pathway (Rapport + Empathy + Trust + Hope + Urgency) that the assumptive close is all you need. If your team is having to ask for the sale they are doing sales wrong. And don’t confuse earning the right to close with asking for the sale. The Sales Leader’s Role in Creating a World-Class Sales Experience Your job as a sales leader is to ensure your team understands that the only thing – above all else – is the sales experience they provide to each potential customer. That customer knows that they have the power and the feeling of unlimited choice. Which means they will decide who to give their money to based on the experience they have with buying from a company. How can you shift your team away from the numbers game mentality to actually providing a world class sales experience to each and every person they speak with?
By Jason Cutter February 17, 2025
The Abundance of Options Today we all have lots of options. While writing this I could speak into my phone and order whatever I want. I can get food delivered before I finish writing this article. I could get a TV delivered to my door before I wake up tomorrow. When someone wants to buy something, they are armed with as much information as they want to access. They can research, read reviews, and watch videos about a product or company. The Shift in Power to the Buyer Because of this, the power balance of sales has shifted away from the salesperson and company to the buyer. Knowledge is power – and they now have all the knowledge they want. With knowing that they have ultimate choice of what to buy (internet and globalization has led to the ability to order anything you want from anywhere…so you are no longer limited to the stores you can drive to and what they have on hand), it means that everything is a commodity in their minds. Nothing is unique or special. Everything is interchangeable. Does the Sales Experience Even Matter? So, this means the sales experience doesn’t matter anymore. There is no reason to put effort into the sales process, the conversations with potential customers. No value in spending time trying to ‘help’ people – since they just view products, salespeople, and companies as interchangeable. You are not special, so there is no benefit in caring. They will walk into your store, and they will decide what they want. They fill out your online for, and they decide if they answer when you call and how the call will go. They walk up to your event/booth, and they decide how the interaction will go and if they want to listen to your elevator pitch. They will let you know if they are interested in moving forward. They will let you know how they want to buy. So, like I said above, there is no real value anymore in the sales experience. Or could it actually be valuable? Is it possible that all that matters IS the sales experience? If people feel they have ultimate information and control of the buying process, how do they decide on what to buy and who to buy from? When I search on Amazon for a product type I have never purchased before, how do I pick? When I want to go shopping for garden supplies for the house, how do I pick where to go? When I need to buy a new fridge, who will I hand my money over to? The cheapest place with terrible service? The place with reasonable prices and great service? The Sales Experience Shapes the Decision I choose based on the sales experience that I will receive. With everything else being equal, I (and I believe most people) will select the place to shop at or the products to buy online based on the experience I receive. To me all that matters is the experience. While I am trying to buy something. Once I receive it – ensure it does what I need it to do. With the feeling of unlimited choices, it can actually be harder now to buy something that in the past. People get into analysis paralysis more often. Which means that for consumers to buy something new they need help. They need a professional salesperson. They need a sales experience that matches their expectations. They want a guide who will help them make the right decision for them, with an experience that goes above and beyond what more people receive any more when they walk into a store, call a company’s toll-free number, or visit a website and have to fill out a form. If you want to succeed in sales – the only thing that matters is the sales experience you provide.
By Jason Cutter February 13, 2025
The Balance of Effort in Sales The blogs this week have been about the other person going most of the way. Whether it’s a prospective customer and your salesperson, where the salesperson truly can’t want the deal or make most of it happen for that customer to truly be successful. On the path for that prospect to becoming a customer, they should go at least 51/49. Whether it’s your team and their manager, the manager can’t want the team to succeed more than the team actually wants it for themselves. It’s not scalable for the coach (manager) to run on the field every play to win the game for the salespeople. What about sales ops processes and systems? What about the tools available to the sales team and the ones that are classified as sales enablement? In a reversal of philosophy, I believe the sales ops processes should go 90, the team should only have to go 10. Why Do We Need Salespeople? Let’s start where it matters – what is the point of having salespeople? I know many owners question the need and desire to have salespeople. They are hard to manage, tough to deal with, always want more money (potentially for doing less work and closing less deals), and are very resistant to change. Of course, that is a generalization. Of course, there are salespeople who don’t check those boxes. However, having worked with a lot of teams in a lot of industries, that generalization isn’t completely wrong or unfair. So if there is even a small part of that which is accurate, why would we even mess with the messiness of having salespeople? Of needing to employ and manage humans? The Human Element in Sales We need them. That’s why. Even in 2025, AI and technology has not successfully replicated the requirements of sales – which is about helping a human (prospect/customer) make the right decision and move outside of their comfort zone to buy something new. It still takes your human (salesperson) to persuade that other human. It’s why I say all the time that its not B2B, B2C, Retail, SaaS, etc. – it’s H2H. Sure, people can buy something online or even in a store without speaking to someone. But if it’s a considered purchase where there are options and decisions to be considered – it still takes a human being involved. That means ultimately your human (salesperson) has one job, and one job only – persuade the right prospective humans to buy. Minimizing Distractions for Salespeople Everything outside of that mission, task, focus is a distraction that takes away from their highest and best use. Imagine if we had a surgeon who had to prep the room, prep the patient, schedule the surgery and meetings, and do all the parts of the surgery themselves. Nope – they show up for the surgery and do what they do best. Then they take off their gown, gloves, and walk away to get cleaned up and move on to the next thing. Your goal as a sales ops leader is to support the team with systems and processes that allow them to focus on the one thing you need them for. The human part. It would be amazing if they could show up, talk to people, and make sales happen. Of course, there is more that they (and any professional) need to do before, during, and after the sales conversation. But your goal is to minimize all that. Every hour that your salespeople aren’t selling or doing sales-related activities, they aren’t moving revenue forward. The Ultimate Goal of Sales Ops What processes can you put in place that go 90 percent of the way, where the salesperson can do the last 10 percent? An example would be building an email campaign that runs automatically, and when the right people reply, the salesperson gets involved in getting that person from email to phone call. Another example would be your CRM serving up people for the salesperson to call – leads or anyone in the sales pipeline flow – with all the backstory, research, data, intel needed for them to review it then take action. What can you put into place that takes away as much distraction and effort from your sales team such that they can focus on the one thing you need to focus on – other humans?
By Jason Cutter February 12, 2025
The Danger of Doing Too Much as a Sales Leader Alright – so maybe they don’t need to go 90. In true servant leadership mode, you would go way more than 10% of the way to your team. But you have to be careful, as a sales leader. The inclination might be to do it all for them. To help them close their sales. To make excuses for them to your leadership as to why they aren’t closing more sales. Especially considering the very high likelihood that you are a sales manager because you were a great salesperson in the role that you are now managing. And there is a slight chance that you are a player-coach…so you are leading and selling. This can make it really tough not to want to run out on the field to win the game each time. But that doesn’t scale. That doesn’t lead to increased results. You can only sell so much as one person. Creating a Culture of Ownership So, you need to have people on your team that are coming to you. What does that look like? The pinnacle is a salesperson who doesn’t close a deal, comes to you right away and asks for feedback. They want some critiques as to where they could have done things better, different that would have led to the desired result – a closed sale. That takes a healthy level of ego by a professional who has the ultimate growth mindset. They know there are always ways to improve. They want to improve. And they are willing to risk their ego (and the internal, protective, primal part of our brain that doesn’t want to risk our place in the tribe) by asking for feedback that could be negative. Whenever you can, encourage that type of response. Ensure that the team knows that the team itself, and you as their leader, is a safe space – where the goal is to improve, grow, win and that everything done to support each other is done in that mode. They truly have to feel safe to share their mistakes and to get support in learning how to do more, better. Feedback That Drives Growth Part of this takes team and individual meetings that are actually filled with positive support. That doesn’t mean it’s always positive, motivational fluff. It’s not even about the shallow strategy of the feedback sandwich. Its about being real, honest, and empathetic – meaning “I see you are here, I know you want to be there, I will help you get there – even if its hard and it means saying hard things.” It should never feel mean or abusive or like an attack. But you can give some really direct feedback that will sting that ego I mentioned, but the person will know the intent behind it. The second part is hiring this type of person. Hiring people for the team that wants to win, grow, succeed. And they know that you don’t get better by being coddled, sheltered, or protected. You want people who don’t like the thought of perpetually living safely in their comfort zone. And they are excited about the opportunity to be a part of a team that pushes everyone, empathetically, outside of their comfort zone. Are You Leading or Just Managing? If you find yourself as a leader having to push your team, or going to them most of the time, or most of the way mentally – then they see you as a manager not a leader. They see you as someone who manages them, pushes them, and wants them to do things they don’t want to do. I have written some blogs here that go into what your role should be – as a leader, not a manager. Pulling people along with you, inspiring people, and supporting yourself with a team of people who want to win. Not just those that want to show up, do as little as they can and hopefully go unnoticed (yet – complain about not making enough money and how the comp plan isn’t fair, or the leads are bad, or their schedule means they can’t be successful.) Make sure your team knows that they need to come to you – at least 51/49. They should be asking for help, guidance, training, feedback, and support more than you are having to push it down onto them.
By Jason Cutter February 3, 2025
If you have seen the movie Hitch, then you know the scene. Will Smith’s character (Hitch) is trying to coach Kevin James’ character (Albert) on how to finish out his upcoming first date. He is giving him pointers, one being that if his date fumbles with her keys at the door, it could mean she wants a kiss. So Hitch wants to see if Albert knows what to do – for a good night kiss. Hitch gives him the advice “you go 90 percent, and then wait for her to go 10%” which Albert then asks “wait for how long?” Hitch: “as long as it takes.” Albert leads in, Hitch is holding back to see if Albert will wait, and then Albert goes all the way and gives him a kiss. Hitch gets upset, and says “You go 90, I go 10 – you don’t go the whole 100%.” The Sales Analogy Kissing our prospective customers is not acceptable (just ask HR!). But the concept is the same. You don’t want to ever make 100% of the effort for your prospective customers. You don’t want to be the one who is doing all the work. Fundamentally, it is not good practice to want the deal more than the other person. When you go your 90, you need to wait – as long as it takes – for the prospect to go to their 10. And I would say that you want to go somewhere between 10-49, in reality. How Successful Sales Professionals Balance Effort Successful sales professionals know how far they have to go to meet the prospect where they are, while also knowing how much effort the prospect needs to put in to show they are committed. Where most salespeople get in trouble is they get desperate. They want the sale (kiss) more than the other person and they go the full 100%. Of course, persistence is important. And you won’t get what you don’t ask for (although…if you have followed me for any length of time, you will know I am very against having to ask for the sale). But you also have to ensure that your prospects actually want what you are selling. And they want it for their reasons and their motivations. They are driven to pursue your production option(s). They must go 10, 40, 60% of the way to you. The Pitfall of Chasing Your Prospect Just like courtship and relationships – if you find yourself chasing and one-sided-pursing the other person then it means you want it more than they do. It also means they own you. You are essentially begging them for the relationship – convincing, manipulating, begging, bribing, persuading your way forward. Which means they consciously and/or subconsciously know that they are in control. Because if they say no, you will keep pursuing and offering solutions. In sales – that looks like a salesperson who is calling, emailing, stalking a prospect – making offers, offering discounts and trials, and trying to find any way to make deal work. They are going 90-100% of the way for the prospect, not requiring them to go anywhere towards the agreement. This will end terribly. If they do decide to buy – taking the discount, free trial, taking the sale bait – they will not be happy (since they weren’t bought in for their reasons), they will look for reasons confirming why they didn’t really want to buy anyway, and they will know that they own you. Your company will have to convince them on a regular basis to stay in the relationship. The Right Balance for Customer Ownership You fundamentally need that prospective customer to come to you. Not 100% where you are just an Order Taker. But potentially 51% of the way – so they want it more than you. The more you can get them across that 50/50 threshold, the more they will be a satisfied customer. But remember – at 51/49 – they still need persuading, they still need to understand the value of your product for where they ultimately want to be in their life/business, and they still need your support. They lean in the right amount, you lean in the right amount = sales magic!
Show More
Share by: